RipCompass
- Storage
- No ongoing fee
- Withdrawal
- $1.99/card + shipping; +$4.99 before 90 days
THE VAULT GUIDE
Best vaults for TCG & Pokémon cards
Your graded Charizard, raw Yu-Gi-Oh! singles and sealed One Piece boxes need different storage routes. Compare card vault services by accepted format, exit costs and the way you want to sell or keep your collection.
By RipCompass teamUpdated September 23, 2026Our top 3 vaults
- Storage
- Listing-dependent fees
- Withdrawal
- US standard from $5.99; additional-card fees
- Storage
- Free for eligible $50+ items
- Withdrawal
- 1% + shipping; 3% within first 90 days
Compare card vault fees and withdrawal times
Amounts use each provider’s quoted currency. Storage, withdrawal handling and shipping are separate charges.
| Provider / useful for | Score | Vault location | Storage | Withdrawal | Dispatch & delivery | External intake |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PSA Vault Graded-card collectors who want PSA and eBay integration | 8.5/10RipCompass score | United States · Delaware | No recurring storage fee advertised | $1.99/card; an additional $4.99/card before 90 days, subject to exceptions | No verified current public dispatch promise; confirm when requesting shipment | Supported authenticated slabs; raw cards excluded |
| COMC Raw-single collectors seeking consignment and shipment consolidation | 7.5/10RipCompass score | United States · Washington | Depends on listing status, asking price and enhanced-security rules | Shipping service and item-count charges; separate sale/cash-out fees | Live destination and service quote; intake processing can range from 2 to 16 weeks | Supported authentic raw and graded singles; paid processing tiers |
| Fanatics Collect Vault Collectors combining authenticated cards, other collectibles and marketplace selling | 8.3/10RipCompass score | United States · Oregon | Eligible standard items $50+ free to vault; lower-value and larger-item charges apply | 3% of insured value within first 90 days; 1% thereafter, plus shipping/insurance | Single item usually 5–7 business days to dispatch, sometimes 10–15; larger orders 10–15 | Supported slabs and approved authenticated collectibles; raw items need authentication |
| Alt Vault Collectors wanting graded-card tools and an option to store raw cards | 7.8/10RipCompass score | United States · Delaware | No recurring storage fee | Percentage-based outtake; terms depend on purchase origin and holding period | Allow two business days for outbound processing, then carrier transit | Supported graded cards, raw cards and eligible packs/wax; charges vary |
| Collector Crypt Vault Graded cards represented by transferable blockchain assets | 5.8/10RipCompass score | Location unconfirmed · Depends on custodian | Current public storage tariff not confirmed | Live quote based on the cards and shipping address | Card-specific estimate; partner-vault holdings can take longer | Graded consumer card submissions; sealed submissions not accepted |
| Arena Club Vault Grading, trading and storing eligible slabs in one account | 7.5/10RipCompass score | United States · Oregon | Active account in good standing required; confirm ongoing fees at submission | $1 per card, plus shipping and insurance | Up to one week to process and dispatch, then carrier transit | AC, PSA, BGS, SGC and CGC slabs; raw cards through paid grading |
| Courtyard Vault Keeping and trading cards already in a Courtyard collection | 6.5/10RipCompass score | United States · Delaware | No stated storage or vault insurance charge | Destination-based shipping and applicable taxes at checkout | Up to 10 business days processing before carrier transit | External card submissions currently paused |
Choose by card format, not just by game
GRADED SINGLESPokémon slabsCheck accepted graders, item values and per-card retrieval fees.
RAW INVENTORYYu-Gi-Oh! & MTGCheck set eligibility, processing costs and condition services.
SEALED PRODUCTSOne Piece boxesBox dimensions and sealed-product acceptance need separate confirmation.
DIGITAL OWNERSHIPTokenised cardsCheck wallet control, custody, token redemption and physical shipping.
Best vault for graded Pokémon cards
PSA is a natural starting point for eligible graded cards when you want its eBay selling workflow and published withdrawal schedule. Compare Fanatics Collect if you prefer its auction marketplace, and Alt if you want its graded-card inventory and selling tools. The card’s grader is separate from the company physically storing it.
Best option for raw TCG cards
COMC deserves a separate look because its model handles eligible raw-card inventory as well as graded cards. This can be more relevant to a collection of individual game cards than a slab-focused service. Per-card processing and seller costs matter especially when each card has a low resale value.
Best vault for Yu-Gi-Oh!, One Piece and Magic cards
There is no single winner across all three games and all formats. For graded singles, compare the accepted-grader list and withdrawal bill. For raw cards, confirm the exact game and set with the service. For sealed boxes, obtain explicit acceptance rather than infer it from a trading-card category.
TCG vaults and pack-opening accounts
Courtyard and Collector Crypt connect physical custody to tokenised collections. Arena Club combines its vault with grading, trading and pack features. Buying a pack can put a card in one of these inventories, but that is different from sending your own collection into the vault. Our mystery pack comparison covers buying packs; these reviews focus on keeping and retrieving the cards.
More TCG vaults
- Storage
- No ongoing fee
- Withdrawal
- 1–3% + shipping, depending on holding period/origin
- Storage
- Confirm with provider
- Withdrawal
- Card-specific quote
- Storage
- Confirm ongoing fees
- Withdrawal
- $1/card + shipping & insurance
- Storage
- Free storage & insurance
- Withdrawal
- Shipping quote; external intake paused
How we selected these vaults
This shortlist prioritises accepted card formats, supported graders and the cost of storing and retrieving TCG collections. Raw cards, graded singles and sealed boxes have different intake rules.
See our full comparison method, worked vault fee examples and guide to depositing and withdrawing cards.
Frequently asked questions
Which vault should I use for graded Pokémon cards?
Compare PSA for its eligible-slab and eBay workflow, Fanatics Collect for its marketplace and auctions, and Alt for collection management. The best fit depends on whether you plan to sell the card inside the platform or withdraw it physically.
Can I store raw Yu-Gi-Oh! or Magic cards in a vault?
COMC handles eligible raw singles through its processing service. Alt accepts raw storage but does not support selling raw cards. PSA Vault excludes raw cards. Confirm the exact game and set before using a raw-card submission route.
Can I send sealed Pokémon or One Piece boxes?
Sealed-product acceptance is separate from graded-card acceptance. Fanatics Collect documents approved sealed items with format-dependent fees; Alt lists graded packs and wax in its fee schedule. Collector Crypt excludes sealed consumer deposits. Confirm the specific box before mailing.
Should I grade a card before vaulting it?
Use the required intake format and your intended outcome. PSA Vault requires eligible encapsulated cards. Arena Club offers a grade-and-vault route. For a low-value raw single, grading and future retrieval can cost more than the card itself.